ePrints Repository

Is there a crisis in school science education in the UK?

Smith, Emma (2010) Is there a crisis in school science education in the UK? Educational Review, 62 (2). pp. 189-202. ISSN 0013-1911

PDF - Adobe Acrobat 9 Pro (88Kb)

URL of Published Version: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/00131911003637014

Identification Number/DOI: 10.1080/00131911003637014

This paper reviews the extent to which contemporary concerns over the recruitment, training and retention of scientists have persisted among science education policy makers. Drawing upon key government reports that have been commissioned in order to review the position of science education and training over the last 90 years, we consider the historical context of contemporary 'moral panics' about the position of science education in schools. Three themes emerge: the nature and purpose of the school science curriculum, the recruitment of science undergraduates, and the teaching of science in schools. The review suggests that many of the concerns which pre-occupy us today, such as the perceived ‘quality’ of the science teaching workforce, are the very same that existed when science was first introduced as a school subject. This raises issues about the role of policy in influencing educational change more generally but also questions whether there ever was a ‘golden age’ for science education in the UK.

Type of Work:Article
Date:May 2010 (Publication)
School/Faculty:Colleges (2008 onwards) > College of Social Sciences
Faculties (to 1997) > Faculty of Education
Schools (1998 to 2008) > School of Education
Department:Education and Social Justice

Adlam, G.H.J., (1919), Compulsion by examination, School Science Review, 1(2), pp33-36.

BBC (2007), Foreigners ‘prop up UK science’, BBC news online, 13th September 2007.

Bell, J.C., (1915), Editorial: the teaching of natural science, Journal of Educational Psychology, 6(10), pp634-635

Bell, J.F., Malacova, E., Shannon, M., (2003), The changing pattern of A level/AS uptake in England, The Curriculum Journal, 16(3), pp391-400.

Bell, J.F., Malacova, E., Shannon, M., (2003a), The changing pattern of A level/AS uptake in England, paper presented at the BERA conference September 2003.

Blair, T., (2006), Our Nation’s Future – Science, speech given to the Royal Society, Oxford, UK, 3rd November 2006, accessed October 2008, from www.number10.gov.uk/Page10342

Brown, G., (2009), The Romanes Lecture given at the Sheldonian Theatre Oxford, 27th February 2009, accessed May 2009 from www.number10.gov/Page18472

CBI (2008), Taking stock: CBI Education and skills survey 2008, London: CBI accessed June 2009 from http://www.cbi.org.uk/pdf/skills_report0408.pdf

Coe, R., Searle, J., Barmby, P., Jones, K., Higgins, S., (2008), Relative difficulty of examinations in different subjects, Report for SCORE, accessed May 2009 from http://sv.iop.org/News/Community_News_Archive/2008/file_30371.doc

Croxford, L., (1997), Participation in science subjects: the effect of the Scottish curriculum framework, Research Papers in Education, 12(1), pp69-89

Committee to Enquire into the Position of Natural Science in the Educational System of Great Britain (1918), Natural Science in Education: Being the Report of the Committee to Enquire into the Position of Natural Science in the Educational System of Great Britain, London: HMSO (the Thomson report).

Committee of Inquiry into the teaching of mathematics in schools (1982), Mathematics Counts: Report of the Committee of Inquiry into the teaching of mathematics in schools, London: HMSO (the Cockroft report).

Committee on Higher Education (1963), Higher Education, Report of the Committee appointed by the Prime Minister under the Chairmanship of Lord Robbins, London: HMSO, (the Robbins Report)

Council for Scientific Policy (1968), Inquiry into the flow of candidates into science and technology in Higher Education, London: HMSO, (the Dainton report).

Delamont, S., (1989), Knowledgeable Women, London: Routledge

Duckworth, D., Entwistle, N.J., (1974), The swing from science: a perspective from hindsight, Educational Research, 17, pp48-53.

Gill, P., (1999), The physics/maths problem again, Physics Education, 34(2) pp83-87.

The Guardian (2008), Women in Science, Engineering and Technology, The Guardian newspaper, 30th October 2008, pp2-23.

Holman, J., (2005), Bring on the science specialists, Times Education Supplement, 28th October 2005, p21.

Hooper, D., (1980), A national problem, Physics Education, 15, pp217-219.

House of Commons (2008), House of Commons Innovation, Universities, Science and Skills Committee Science Budget Allocations Fourth Report of Session 2007–08, London: HMSO.

Howson, J., Sprigade, A., (2006), From pupil to scientist – more or less? Paper presented at The Royal Society Conference ‘Increasing the uptake of science post-16’ 10th March 2006.

HMT (2004), Science and Innovation Investment Framework 2004-2014, London: HM Treasury.

Hurd, P.D., (1991), Closing the educational gap between science technology and society, Theory into Practice, 30(4), pp251-259.

Jenkins, E., (1979), From Armstrong to Nuffield, Studies in Twentieth Century Science Education in England and Wales, London: John Murray.

Jenkins, E., (2007), School science: a questionable construct? Journal of Curriculum Studies, 39(3), pp265-282.

Jones, C.L., Littlejohn, G.M., McPherson, A.F., (1973), Aversion to science teaching as a factor in the choice of science subjects, Science Studies, 3(2), pp173-179.

Jones, H., (2009), Fundamental problems, The Times Higher Education Supplement, 2nd July 2009.

Layton, D., (1981), The Schooling of Science in England, 1854-1939, in The Parliament of Science, MacLeod, R., Collins, P., (Eds.), Northwood: Science Reviews Ltd.

Leitch Review of Skills, (2006), Prosperity for all in the global economy - world class skills: Final Report, London: HMSO.

Margo, J., Benton, M., Withers, K., Sodha, S., with Tough, S., (2008), Those who can?, London: IPPR

McPherson, A., (1969), ‘Swing from Science’ or retreat from reason? Universities Quarterly, Vol. 24, pp29-43.

McVey, P.J., (1970), Are public examinations fair to science students? Physics Education, 13, pp28-32.

Ministry of Education (1953), Graduate teachers of mathematics and science: a report of the national advisory council on the training and supply of teachers, London: HMSO (the Morris report).

Ministry of Education (1959), 15 to 18: a report of the Central Advisory Council for Education (England), London: HMSO (the Crowther report).

Moor, H., Jones, M., Johnson, F., Martin K., Cowell, E., Bojke, C., (2006), Mathematics and Science in Secondary Schools: The Deployment of Teachers and Support Staff to Deliver the Curriculum, DfES Research Report 708, Nottingham: DfES

Pollard, A., (1969), ‘O’ and ‘A’ level: keeping up the standards, in Black Paper Two: the crisis in education, Cox, C.B., Dyson, A.E., London: Critical Quarterly Society.

OECD (2007), Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA), accessed September 2008 from http://www.oecd.org/dataoecd/15/13/39725224.pdf

Osborne, J., Simon, S., Collins, S., (2003), Attitudes towards science: a review of the literature and its implications, International Journal of Science Education, 25(9), pp1049-79.

Roberts, G., (2002), SET for Success: The study of people with science, technology engineering and mathematical skills, London: HMSO.

Royal Society (2006), Increasing the uptake of science post-16, report of a Royal Society Conference Held on March 10th 2006.

Royal Society (2007), The UK’s mathematics and Science teaching workforce, A state of the nation report 2007, London: The Royal Society.

Royal Society (2008), Science and mathematics education, 14 –19 A ‘state of the nation’ report on the participation and attainment of 14–19 year olds in science and mathematics in the UK, 1996–2007, accessed June 2009 from

Save British Science (2005), Science Agenda for the Period 2005-2010, Selkirk, F., Subject Choice at GCE Advanced Level, Universities Quarterly, Winter 1972, pp74-89.

Smith, A., (2004), Making Mathematics Count: The report of Professor Adrian Smith’s Inquiry into Post-14 Mathematics Education, accessed June 2009 http://www.tda.gov.uk/upload/resources/pdf/m/mathsinquiry_finalreport.pdf

Smithers, A., Robinson, P., (2005), Physics in Schools and Colleges: Teacher Deployment and Student Outcomes, University of Buckingham.

Smithers, A., Robinson, P., (2006), Physics in School and Universities, II Patterns and Policies, University of Buckingham.

Society of Chemical Industry (2006), Strategic chemistry-based science education into the 21st Century, Paper 2, London: SOCI Insight.

Starling, E.H., (1918), Natural science in education: notes on the report of the Committee on the Position of Natural Science in the Education System of Great Britain, The Lancet, 192(4959), pp365-8

Sykes, R., (1998) Podium: Science must allay the public’s fears; from an inaugural speech by the President of the Association for the Advancement of Science, The Independent, 14th September 1998.

The Times (2008), Can’t do attitude to maths ‘has cost economy £9bn’, The Times Newspaper, 3rd June 2008, page 9.

Turner, F.M., (1980), Public Science in Britain 1880-1919, Isis, 71(4), pp589-608.

UK Mathematics Foundation (2005), Where will the next generation of UK mathematicians come from? University of Manchester: Manchester Institute or Mathematical Sciences

Walford, G., (1985), The construction of a curriculum area: science in society’ British Journal of Sociology of Education, 692), pp155-171.

Young, M., (1976), The Schooling of Science, in Explorations in the politics of school knowledge, Whitty, G., Young, M., (eds), Driffield: Studies in Education Ltd,
Nafferton Books.

Keywords:education, social justice, education policy, science, education and social justice, secondary education, secondary schools, science crisis, teaching, teacher recruitment
Subjects:LB2361 Curriculum
Q Science (General)
LB Theory and practice of education
LB1603 Secondary Education. High schools
L Education (General)
Institution:University of Birmingham
Copyright Holders:University of Birmingham
ID Code:592
Local Holdings:
Export Reference As : ASCII + BibTeX + Dublin Core + EndNote + HTML + METS + MODS + OpenURL Object + Reference Manager + Refer + RefWorks
Share this item :
QR Code for this page

Repository Staff Only: item control page