ePrints Repository

Perpetrating disaffection: Schooling as an international problem

Harber, Clive (2008) Perpetrating disaffection: Schooling as an international problem. Educational Studies, 34 (5). pp. 457-467. ISSN 0305-5698

PDF - Adobe Acrobat 9 Pro (75Kb)

URL of Published Version: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/03055690802288445

Identification Number/DOI: 10.1080/03055690802288445

This paper argues that, despite evidence of widespread disaffection, school is often regarded as the default position for educational provision, a given good. If there is disaffection with, and resistance to, schooling, then it is pupils and parents that are the problem, not school itself. Yet there is considerable evidence that schooling does not necessarily or automatically benefit either society as a whole or the individuals who attend and that, as a result, it creates disaffection with itself. Rejection of schooling is therefore very far from being an irrational or ill-considered act. The paper reviews evidence supporting this argument including both the failure of schools to protect young people from danger and violence and also their direct role in actively perpetrating
violence and threatening the safety of those they are there to protect. The paper ends by arguing that disaffection with schooling stems from its fundamental nature and purposes
which have been shaped by its historical origins. While schooling remains as it is,
disaffection and resistance will continue to be an inbuilt and often logical response.

Type of Work:Article
Date:2008 (Publication)
School/Faculty:Colleges (2008 onwards) > College of Social Sciences
Department:Department of Education and Social Justice

Adams,R. (1991) Protests By Pupils : Empowerment, Schooling and the State (London:The Falmer Press)

Alexander,R. (2000) Culture and Pedagogy : International Comparisons in Primary Education (Oxford:Blackwell)

Asthana,A. and Hinscliff,G. (2006) ‘How Poor Children miss Out on the Best Schools’, The Observer 5/2

Bancroft,S. (2006) ‘As Row Over Caste Quoya Rages, India’s Real Scandal is Ignored’, Times Educational Supplement 2/6

Behal,S. (2002) ‘Caste cruelty makes school a nightmare’, Times Educational Supplement 26/4

Blindel,J. (2006) ‘Absent Enemies’, Education Guardian 21/11

Bowles,S. and Gintis,H. (1976) Schooling in Capitalist America (London:Routledge and Kegan Paul)

Boyle,P. (1999) Class Formation and Civil Society: The Politics of Education in Africa (Aldershot:Ashgate)

Brettingham,M. (2006) ‘Give Us the Freedom to Teach’, Times Educational Supplement 17/11

Brohi,N. and Ajaib,A. (2006) ‘Violence Against Girls in the Education System of Pakistan’, in F. Leach, and C. Mitchell (Eds.) (2006) Combating Gender Violence In and Around Schools Stoke On Trent:Trentham Books)

Cushman,K. (2003) Fires in the Bathroom (New York:The New Press) Davies, I., Gregory, I. & Riley, S. (1999) Good Citizenship and Educational Provision (London: Falmer Press)

Devine,J. (1996) Maximum Security : The Culture of Violence in Inner-City Schools (Chicago:University of Chicago Press)

Douse,M. (2005) ‘Learning and Laughter – and let the Livelihood Come Later’, paper delivered to the 8th UKFIET International Conference on Education and Development, University of Oxford.

Duncan,N. (2006) ‘Girls Violence and Aggression Against Other Girls: femininity and bullying in UK schools’, in F.Leach and C. Mitchell (Eds.) Combating Gender Violence in and Around Schools (Stoke On Trent:Trentham Books)

Fitzgerald,M. (2006) ‘Japan Tries to Stem Wave of Pupil Suicides’, Times Educational Supplement 24/11

Gardiner,B. (2003) ‘Foreword’ to Burke,C. and Grosvenor,I. (2003) The School That I’d Like (London:RoutledgeFalmer)

Garner,R. and Russell,B. (2006) ‘Stranglehold’ The Independent 15/6

Green,A. (1990) Education and State Formation (London:Macmillan)

Hallak,J. and Poisson,M. (2006) Corrupt Schools, Corrupt Universities : What Can Be Done? (Paris:IIEP)

Harber,C. (2004) Schooling As Violence (London:RoutledgeFalmer)

Hill,S. (2006) School Works Online Poll (www.school-works.org.uk)

Human Rights Watch (1999) Broken People : Caste Violence Against India’s “Untouchables” (Human Rights Watch:New York)

Human Rights Watch (2001) Scared at School : Sexual Violence Against Girls in South African Schools (New York:Human Rights Watch)

Humphreys,S. (2006) ‘Corporal Punishment As Gendered Practice’, in F.Leach and C. Mitchell (Eds.) Combating Gender Violence in and Around Schools (Stoke On Trent:Trentham Books)

Katz,A., Buchanan,A. and Bream,V. (2001) Bullying in Britain : Testimonies from Teenagers (East Molesey:Young Voice)

Leach,F. and Mitchell,C. (Eds.) Combating Gender Violence in and Around Schools (Stoke On Trent:Trentham Books)

Lee,J. (2005) ‘Worries Over Tuning in to Track Pupils’, Times Educational Supplement 4/3

Martin,C. (1994) Schooling in Mexico (Aldershot:Avebury)

Meyer,E. (2006) ‘Gendered Harassment in North America: recognising homophobia and heterosexism among students, in F.Leach and C. Mitchell (Eds.) Combating Gender Violence in and Around Schools (Stoke On Trent:Trentham Books)

Molteno,M., Ogadhoh,K., Cain,E. and Crumpton,B. (2000) Towards Responsive Schools : Supporting Better Schooling for Disadvantaged Children (London:Department for International Development/Save the Children)

Nelson Mandela Foundation (2005) Emerging Voices (Cape Town:HSRC Press)

Oshako,T. (Ed.) (1997) Violence at School : Global Issues and Interventions (Paris:UNESCO)

Osler,A. (2006) ‘Excluded Girl; interpersonal, institutional and structural violence in schooling’, Gender and Education 18, 6 pp571-589

Phillips,S. (2006) ‘Less Tolerance for Drug Raids on Pupils’, Times Educational Supplement 6/2

Rahman,M. (2004a) ’78 Children Die as Fire Sweeps School in India’, The Guardian 17/7

Rahman,M. (2004b) ‘Schools Ordered to Close in Wake of Indian Fire Deaths’, The Guardian 19/7

Richardson,C. (2004) ‘After School, Clubs’, The Guardian 15/11

Rimer,S. (2004) ‘Unruly Students As Delinquents’, International Herald Tribune 5/1

Roland,E. and Munthe,E. (1989) Bullying : An International Perspective (London:David Fulton)

Ross Epp,J. (1996) ‘Schools, Complicity and Sources of Violence’, in J. Ross Epp and A. Watkinson (Eds.) Systemic Violence : How Schools Hurt Children (London:The Falmer Press)

Ruiz,R.O. (1998) ‘Indiscipline or violence? The problem of bullying in school’, Prospects XVIII, No. 4 p587-599

Save The Children (2006) ‘Save the Children: Mongolia to Protect over 650,000 Children’ (www.politics.co.uk/press-releases/domestic-policy,children/child-abuse/save-ch)

Slater,J. (2004) ‘Exam Fears Haunt Pupils’, Times Educational Supplement 23/1

Slater,J. (2005) ‘Behaviour: are you winning?’, Times Educational Supplement 4/3

Taylor,M. (006) ‘It’s Official: Class Matters’, Education Guardian 28/2

Teeka-Bhattarai,S. (2006) Corporal Punishment in Schools : Issues, Efforts and Experiences with Children’s Clubs in Nepal’, Paper delivered at ESRC Seminar on Children As Decision-Makers, University of East Anglia.

Tengi-Atinga,G. (2006) ‘Ghanaian Trainee Teachers’ Narratives of Sexual Harassment: A Study of Institutional Practices’, in F. Leach, and C. Mitchell (Eds.)

Townsend,M. (2004) ‘Exam Fears Driving Teenagers to Prozac’, The Observer 6/6

UNESCO (2003) Education Today No.4 January-March

WHO (World Health Organisation) (2002) World Report on Violence and Health (Geneva:WHO)

Yoneyama,S. (2000) ‘Student Discourse on Tokokjohi (School Phobia/Refusal) in Japan: burnout or empowerment?’, British Journal of Sociology of Education
21,1 pp77-94

Zdravomyslova,O. and Gorshkova,I. (2006) ‘The Usual Evil: gender violence in Russian schools’, in F.Leach and C. Mitchell (Eds.) Combating Gender Violence in and Around Schools (Stoke On Trent:Trentham Books)

Keywords:education, social justice, education and social justice, policy, schooling, international, disaffection, resistance, violence,
Subjects:LB Theory and practice of education
LB1603 Secondary Education. High schools
HN Social history and conditions. Social problems. Social reform
LB1501 Primary Education
L Education (General)
Institution:University of Birmingham
Copyright Holders:Taylor & Francis
ID Code:593
Local Holdings:
Export Reference As : ASCII + BibTeX + Dublin Core + EndNote + HTML + METS + MODS + OpenURL Object + Reference Manager + Refer + RefWorks
Share this item :
QR Code for this page

Repository Staff Only: item control page